Net Neutrality Order Stay Summary
The following report was shared with Summit Ridge Group by Morgan Lewis & Bockius’s Andrew Lipman.
We are continuing to assess the substance and implications of yesterday’s ruling by the Sixth Circuit to stay the FCC’s Net Neutrality Order pending judicial review.
The Sixth Circuit’s ruling provided a cogent and succinct history of the development of regulation for broadband under the Communications Act, noting that the FCC “for many years” considered broadband to be an information (not telecommunications) service and that these prior classifications were upheld by the Supreme Court under Chevron (in Brand X). Then in 2015, the FCC for the first time categorized broadband as a telecommunications service, a decision that was later upheld (again, under Chevron) by the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals. But the FCC returned to its prior view of broadband as an information service in 2018, only to reverse course once again in 2024.
The Sixth Circuit pointed to the FCC’s own characterizations of broadband as “absolutely essential” to modern day life, national security, and public safety (along with “decades of debates” in Congress and elsewhere over net neutrality) to support the Court’s conclusion that the issue of classifying broadband involves a Major Question. Unlike other provisions of the Act which permit the FCC to determine whether certain services—like fixed and mobile satellite—should be treated as common carriage, Congress did not clearly grant the FCC discretion to classify broadband providers as common carriers. In other words, Congress gave the FCC clear authority to classify other types of services as common carriage (or not) but did not give the FCC similarly clear direction for broadband. Therefore, the FCC cannot classify broadband as a common carrier service.
As to the other factors relevant to deciding to issue a stay, the Sixth Circuit (without significant elaboration) agreed that the petitioners face delays in product rollouts and other competitive injuries and compliance costs that would be irreparable, and the public interest supports ensuring a correct application of the law.
The Sixth Circuit then rebutted many (but not all) of the arguments raised by the FCC, including that Brand X supports the Net Neutrality Order. On the contrary, says the Sixth Circuit, Brand X was silent on the Major Questions doctrine and dealt with the opposite outcome from today’s Net Neutrality Order (i.e., Brand X upheld a Title I classification). And while the Sixth Circuit acknowledged that the Act provides the FCC with general and ancillary authority to fill regulatory gaps, such general authority does not overcome the issue of Major Questions. The court stated that the more extensive the regulatory authority claimed by the agency, the clearer the statutory delegation of that authority needs to be. Nor did the Sixth Circuit agree that Section 706’s authority to impose some regulation on broadband means that the FCC can regulate all broadband as common carriage, and the FCC’s authority to regulate under Section 706 only applies after the FCC determines that broadband telecommunications is not being timely and reasonably deployed.
The Sixth Circuit turned the FCC’s Order against the agency again with respect to compliance costs and irreparable harms. In its briefing, the FCC argued that the petitioners did not show they will suffer irreparable harm because they did not provide quantitative estimates of expected compliance costs or specific plans impacted by the Order. But the Order itself, notes the Sixth Circuit, concedes that the reclassification would lead to an increase in costs (a cost increase the court is not willing to trade-off in light of the FCC’s exceeding the bounds of its legal authority).
While concurring in the full opinion of the panel, one judge (Chief Judge Sutton, a George W. Bush appointee) issued a separate opinion to offer his view that the “best reading of the statute” is that Congress did not intend for broadband providers to be regulated under Title II. His concurrence also rejects the FCC’s request for deference to the agency’s expertise because “we do not know which group of experts to respect” (that is, those who previously decided that broadband was an information service or those who now argue that it is a telecommunications service), the Title II classification has only applied for three of the 28-year span of the Telecommunications Act, and the timing of FCC’s latest change implies that its most recent view is driven not by the true meaning of the law but by a change in presidential administration.
As noted in the opinion, the ruling does not address the merits of all of the legal arguments raised by the parties, instead resting its merits finding (for now) on Major Questions. For example, the Sixth Circuit did not delve into the details of the parties’ positions on the relevance of Brand X or prior classifications of broadband as a telecommunication service that were upheld (for example, in the Portland case before the Ninth Circuit). Nor did the full panel (setting aside Chief Judge Sutton’s concurrence) opine on the best reading of the statute for purposes of classifying broadband. We expect the parties’ briefs will further expand on their positions and that the merits panel will dig more deeply into the many issues.
In terms of procedural next steps, yesterday’s decision directed that oral argument in the case be held between October 28 and November 1, 2024. That is a fairly quick turnaround from the briefing schedule that currently ends with Petitioners’ optional reply brief on October 2. This sets the court up to issue a decision in the early part of 2025 (although there is no deadline by which the Sixth Circuit must rule).
Importantly, the Sixth Circuit has decided to have a randomly selected panel of three judges (from a total of 29 Sixth Circuit judges) to hear the oral argument. That means that the judges who decided the stay are not necessarily the ones who will hear the oral argument and decide the case. It is possible that none of the judges involved in deciding to stay the Net Neutrality Order will participate in review of the case on the merits. Although the merits panel will not be bound by the decision on the stay motion, it is fairly unlikely that they would disregard a unanimous decision by other judges in the Sixth Circuit. For this reason, along with the substance of the stay order’s analysis, we think the industry petitioners are the most likely victors at this stage of the litigation.
Interestingly, the panel who decided yesterday’s 3-0 ruling consisted of two Democratic appointees (appointed by Presidents Clinton and Biden) and one Republican appointee (appointed by President George W. Bush). This composition signals to us that the issue of the FCC’s authority under the Act to classify broadband as a Title II telecommunications service is unlikely to be swayed heavily by political considerations. The makeup of yesterday’s panel also is notable in that the decision hinged on the issue of Major Questions, a novel and generally more conservative principle of statutory interpretation that seeks to cabin the power of Federal agencies while demanding that Congress speak with more precision when legislating, especially in the context of regulations that will have a significant economic and political impact.
While we will not see a final ruling for several more months, we continue to believe that the Sixth Circuit panel that hears the case later this year is most likely to rule in favor of the broadband providers and formally vacate the FCC’s Net Neutrality Order next year. A decision in favor of the petitioners will almost certainly be appealed by the FCC (FCC Chairwoman Rosenworcel has said that the FCC “will not give up the fight for net neutrality”), but the current composition of the Supreme Court and its views on Major Questions and Chevron make it (in our view) unlikely that the Supreme Court would take up the case. (On the other hand, in the less likely event that the Sixth Circuit merits panel upholds the FCC’s authority, Supreme Court review becomes a greater possibility, because the case would give the Supreme Court an opportunity to apply some of its more recent administrative law rulings.)
Overturning of the Order also will make it more challenging for FCC Chairwoman Rosenworcel to move forward with several of the high priority policy items, including the MTE bulk billing[proceeding and the BGP Routing Security proposals that remain under development.
Click here to return to our blog.