Four Years to Clear the Upper C-band. Less Than a Year to Decide Who Pays:

Announcing the Unofficial Guide for the Upper C-band Transition Summit Ridge Group has published the Unofficial Guide for the Upper C-band Transition (104 pages, 246 footnotes), which lays out that calendar and the decisions inside it for the four groups the Order reaches: incumbent earth station operators, the three eligible satellite operators, airlines and aircraft…

Read More

USF Found Unconstitutional: Morgan Lewis’s Initial Take

Morgan, Lewis & Bockius‘ Andrew Lipman shared the following analysis with Summit Ridge Group: Universal Service Contribution Mechanism Held Unconstitutional In a scathing decision, the Fifth Circuit held today (by a 9–7 majority) that the Universal Service Fund 2022 First Quarter contribution factor is unconstitutional.  The court found that Congress impermissibly delegated its taxing authority…

Read More

Rip & Replace Data Understates Participants Incurred Spending Costs

Participants in the FCC’s Secure and Trusted Communication Program (“SCRP” or “Rip & Replace”) are much closer to hitting their initial 39.5% allocation budgets than publicly available data from their “Spending Reports” or the FCC’s semi-annual report to Congress would suggest.[1] As a leading provider of FCC reimbursement support services, Summit Ridge Group (“Summit Ridge”…

Read More

U-verse is the Regulatory Key to the Proposed AT&T/DIRECTV Merger

AT&T ‘s proposed $48 billion acquisition of DIRECTV is based on two simple business facts – 1) AT&T has broadband but needs a stronger video product to compete with cable; and 2) DIRERCTV needs a voice and broadband product to compete with cable. By combining services the can save money on customer service, back office…

Read More

Conference Summary – More Weak Arguments from Big Companies

I attended the Optimal Coevolution of Mobile Broadband Technology and Spectrum Policy workshop in Washington D.C. on Friday.  A number of leading spectrum policy and technology figures were present. Key takeaways: 1)   Blair Levin (Aspen Institute Fellow and an author of the National Broadband Report) indicated that earlier drafts of the National Broadband Plan included a…

Read More

Wireless Consolidation’s Impact on the Incentive Auctions

Since the discussion of the television broadcast incentive auctions began a few years ago, the US wireless industry has significantly consolidated. In the past 12 months the following major transactions have reshaped the industry: Verizon’s buys Spectrum Co, signaling the probably end of the cable industry’s interest in entering the industry; T-mobile buys MetroPCS and…

Read More

Incentive Auction NPRM & Plight of Low Powered TV Stations

While there has been a lot of discussion about the FCC’s October 2nd Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) for the incentive auctions, the plight of low powered television stations has been somewhat neglected. These stations hold secondary licenses and are allowed to operate on their frequency allocation subject to them not interfering with the primary…

Read More

Foreign Wireless Companies Buying their US Counterparts….

The past few weeks we have seen two major wireless transactions announced.  First Deutsche Telecom backed  T-mobile announced an acquisition MetroPCS and late last week the Japan’s Softbank announced it was paying $20 billion for a 70% interest in Sprint.  Why does foreign firms find US wireless companies so attractive?  On first blush, it does…

Read More

Second Paper on TV Broadcasters’ Property Rights in their FCC License Published

My second paper on television broadcasters’ potential property rights in their spectrum was recently published in the Columbia Science and Technology Law Review. This paper is a detailed legal analysis of the subject.  My prior paper on the subject, was a policy-oriented paper about potential equitable solutions to the dilemma of reallocating television spectrum. Broadcasting Licenses:…

Read More

Television Broadcast Spectrum Reclamation Through Eminent Domain Paper Published

My paper “How the Traditional Property Rights Model Informs the Television Broadcasting Spectrum Rationalization Challenge” has been published in the Hastings Communications and Entertainment Law Journal – 34 Hastings Comm. & Ent. L.J. 145 (2012). While some of the issues have been overshadowed by recent incentive auction legislation, the conceptual framework is likely to be…

Read More